The Right of Way | Page 8

the face a year ago;
also that he had kept a factory girl in affluence for two years. Here was
motive for murder--if motive were to govern them--far greater than
might be suggested by excited conversation which listeners who could
not hear a word construed into a quarrel--listeners who bore the
prisoner at the bar ill-will because he shunned them while in the
lumber-camp. If the prisoner was to be hanged for motive untraceable,
why should not these two women be hanged for motive traceable!

Here was his chance. He appeared to impeach subtly every intelligence
in the room for having had any preconviction about the prisoner's guilt.
He compelled the jury to feel that they, with him, had made the
discovery of the unsound character of the evidence. The man might be
guilty, but their personal guilt, the guilt of the law, would be far greater
if they condemned the man on violable evidence. With a last simple
appeal, his hands resting on the railing before the seat where the jury
sat, his voice low and conversational again, his eyes running down the
line of faces of the men who had his client's life in their hands, he said:
"It is not a life only that is at stake, it is not revenge for a life snatched
from the busy world by a brutal hand that we should heed to-day, but
the awful responsibility of that thing we call the State, which, having
the power of life and death without gainsay or hindrance, should prove
to the last inch of necessity its right to take a human life. And the right
and the reason should bring conviction to every honest human mind.
That is all I have to say."
The crown attorney made a perfunctory reply. The judge's charge was
brief, and, if anything, a little in favour of the prisoner--very little, a
casuist's little; and the jury filed out of the room. They were gone but
ten minutes. When they returned, the verdict was given: "Not guilty,
your Honour!"
Then it was that a woman laughed in the gallery. Then a whispering
voice said across the railing which separated the public from the
lawyers: "Charley! Charley!"
Though Charley turned and looked at the lady who spoke, he made no
response.
A few minutes later, outside the court, as he walked quickly away,
again inscrutable and debonair, the prisoner, Joseph Nadeau, touched
him on the arm and said:
"M'sieu', M'sieu', you have saved my life--I thank you, M'sieu'!"
Charley Steele drew his arm away with disgust. "Get out of my sight!

You're as guilty as hell!" he said.

CHAPTER II
WHAT CAME OF THE TRIAL
"When this is over, Kathleen, I will come to you." So Charley Steele's
eyes had said to a lady in the court room on that last day of the great
trial. The lady had left the court-room dazed and exalted. She, with
hundreds of others, had had a revelation of Charley Steele; had had also
the great emotional experience of seeing a crowd make the 'volte face'
with their convictions; looking at a prisoner one moment with eyes of
loathing and anticipating his gruesome end, the next moment seeing
him as the possible martyr to the machinery of the law. She whose
heart was used to beat so evenly had felt it leap and swell with
excitement, awaiting the moment when the jury filed back into the
court-room. Then it stood still, as a wave might hang for an instant at
its crest ere it swept down to beat upon the shore.
With her as with most present, the deepest feeling in the agitated
suspense was not so much that the prisoner should go free, as that the
prisoner's counsel should win his case. It was as if Charley Steele were
on trial instead of the prisoner. He was the imminent figure; it was his
fate that was in the balance--such was the antic irony of suggestion.
And the truth was, that the fates of both prisoner and counsel had been
weighed in the balance that sweltering August day.
The prisoner was forgotten almost as soon as he had left the court-room
a free man, but wherever men and women met in Montreal that day,
one name was on the lips of all-Charley Steele! In his speech he had
done two things: he had thrown down every barrier of reserve--or so it
seemed-- and had become human and intimate. "I could not have
believed it of him," was the remark on every lip. Of his ability there
never had been a moment's doubt, but it had ever been an
uncomfortable ability, it had tortured foes and made friends anxious.
No one had ever seen him show feeling. If it was a mask, he had worn

it