The Promise of American Life

Promise Of American Life, by
Herbert David Croly

Project Gutenberg's The Promise Of American Life, by Herbert David
Croly This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere at no cost and with
almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or
re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included
with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.net
Title: The Promise Of American Life
Author: Herbert David Croly
Release Date: December 22, 2004 [EBook #14422]
Language: English
Character set encoding: ISO-8859-1
*** START OF THIS PROJECT GUTENBERG EBOOK THE
PROMISE OF AMERICAN LIFE ***

Produced by Sandra Bannatyne and the Online Distributed
Proofreading Team, Produced from images provided by the Million
Book Project

THE PROMISE OF AMERICAN LIFE
BY HERBERT CROLY

New York THE MACMILLAN COMPANY
* * * * *
Set up and electrotyped. Published November, 1909. Reprinted June,
1910; April, 1911; March, 1912.
Norwood Press J.S. Cushing Co.--Berwick & Smith Co. Norwood,
Mass., U.S.A.

Dedicated
TO THE MEMORY OF THE LATE
DAVID GOODMAN CROLY

CONTENTS
CHAPTER I
WHAT IS THE PROMISE OF AMERICAN LIFE?
CHAPTER II
THE FEDERALISTS AND THE REPUBLICANS
CHAPTER III
THE DEMOCRATS AND THE WHIGS
CHAPTER IV
SLAVERY AND AMERICAN NATIONALITY
CHAPTER V

THE CONTEMPORARY SITUATION
CHAPTER VI
REFORM AND THE REFORMERS
CHAPTER VII
RECONSTRUCTION; ITS CONDITIONS AND PURPOSES
CHAPTER VIII
NATIONALITY AND DEMOCRACY
CHAPTER IX
THE AMERICAN DEMOCRACY AND ITS NATIONAL
PRINCIPLES
CHAPTER X
A NATIONAL FOREIGN POLICY
CHAPTER XI
PROBLEMS OF RECONSTRUCTION--PART I
CHAPTER XII
PROBLEMS OF RECONSTRUCTION--PART II
CHAPTER XIII
CONCLUSIONS--THE INDIVIDUAL AND THE NATIONAL
PURPOSE
INDEX

THE PROMISE OF AMERICAN LIFE
CHAPTER I
I
WHAT IS THE PROMISE OF AMERICAN LIFE?
The average American is nothing if not patriotic. "The Americans are
filled," says Mr. Emil Reich in his "Success among the Nations," "with
such an implicit and absolute confidence in their Union and in their
future success that any remark other than laudatory is inacceptable to
the majority of them. We have had many opportunities of hearing
public speakers in America cast doubts upon the very existence of God
and of Providence, question the historic nature or veracity of the whole
fabric of Christianity; but never has it been our fortune to catch the
slightest whisper of doubt, the slightest want of faith, in the chief God
of America--unlimited belief in the future of America." Mr. Reich's
method of emphasis may not be very happy, but the substance of what
he says is true. The faith of Americans in their own country is religious,
if not in its intensity, at any rate in its almost absolute and universal
authority. It pervades the air we breathe. As children we hear it asserted
or implied in the conversation of our elders. Every new stage of our
educational training provides some additional testimony on its behalf.
Newspapers and novelists, orators and playwrights, even if they are
little else, are at least loyal preachers of the Truth. The skeptic is not
controverted; he is overlooked. It constitutes the kind of faith which is
the implication, rather than the object, of thought, and consciously or
unconsciously it enters largely into our personal lives as a formative
influence. We may distrust and dislike much that is done in the name of
our country by our fellow-countrymen; but our country itself, its
democratic system, and its prosperous future are above suspicion.
Of course, Americans have no monopoly of patriotic enthusiasm and
good faith. Englishmen return thanks to Providence for not being born
anything but an Englishman, in churches and ale-houses as well as in

comic operas. The Frenchman cherishes and proclaims the idea that
France is the most civilized modern country and satisfies best the needs
of a man of high social intelligence. The Russian, whose political and
social estate does not seem enviable to his foreign contemporaries,
secretes a vision of a mystically glorified Russia, which condemns to
comparative insipidity the figures of the "Pax Britannica" and of "La
Belle France" enlightening the world. Every nation, in proportion as its
nationality is thoroughly alive, must be leavened by the ferment of
some such faith. But there are significant differences between the faith
of, say, an Englishman in the British Empire and that of an American in
the Land of Democracy. The contents of an Englishman's national idea
tends to be more exclusive. His patriotism is anchored to the historical
achievements of Great Britain and restricted thereby. As a good patriot
he is bound to be more preoccupied with the inherited fabric of national
institutions and traditions than he is with the ideal and more than
national possibilities of the future. This very loyalty to the national
fabric does, indeed, imply an important ideal content; but the national
idealism of an Englishman, a German, or even a Frenchman, is heavily
mortgaged