Occasional Papers

Occasional Papers

The Project Gutenberg EBook of Occasional Papers, by R.W. Church
This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere at no cost and with
almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or
re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included
with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.net
Title: Occasional Papers Selected from The Guardian, The Times, and
The Saturday Review, 1846-1890
Author: R.W. Church
Release Date: April 3, 2004 [EBook #11771]
Language: English
Character set encoding: ISO-8859-1
*** START OF THIS PROJECT GUTENBERG EBOOK
OCCASIONAL PAPERS ***

Produced by MBP, papeters, and the Online Distributed Proofreading
Team.

OCCASIONAL PAPERS
SELECTED FROM THE GUARDIAN, THE TIMES, AND THE
SATURDAY REVIEW 1846-1890
By the late R.W. CHURCH, M.A., D.C.L. Sometime Rector of
Whatley, Dean of St. Paul's, Honorary Fellow of Oriel College
In Two Vols.--VOL. II
London Macmillan and Co., Limited New York: The Macmillan
Company
1897

First Edition February 1897 Reprinted April 1897

CONTENTS
I MR. GLADSTONE ON THE ROYAL SUPREMACY
II JOYCE ON COURTS OF SPIRITUAL APPEAL
III PRIVY COUNCIL JUDGMENTS
IV SIR JOHN COLERIDGE ON THE PURCHAS CASE
V MR. GLADSTONE'S LETTER ON THE ENGLISH CHURCH
VI DISENDOWMENT
VII THE NEW COURT
VIII MOZLEY'S BAMPTON LECTURES
IX ECCE HOMO
X THE AUTHOR OF "ROBERT ELSMERE" ON A NEW
REFORMATION
XI RENAN'S "VIE DE JÉSUS"
XII RENAN'S "LES APÔTRES"
XIII RENAN'S HIBBERT LECTURES
XIV RENAN'S "SOUVENIRS D'ENFANCE"
XV LIFE OF FREDERICK ROBERTSON
XVI LIFE OF BARON BUNSEN
XVII COLERIDGE'S MEMOIR OF KEBLE
XVIII MAURICE'S THEOLOGICAL ESSAYS
XIX FREDERICK DENISON MAURICE
XX SIR RICHARD CHURCH
XXI DEATH OF BISHOP WILBERFORCE
XXII RETIREMENT OF THE PROVOST OF ORIEL
XXIII MARK PATTISON
XXIV PATTISON'S ESSAYS
XXV BISHOP FRAZER
XXVI NEWMAN'S "APOLOGIA"
XXVII DR. NEWMAN ON THE "EIRENICON"
XXVIII NEWMAN'S PAROCHIAL SERMONS
XXIX CARDINAL NEWMAN
XXX CARDINAL NEWMAN'S COURSE
XXXI CARDINAL NEWMAN'S NATURALNESS
XXXII LORD BLACHFORD

I
MR. GLADSTONE ON THE ROYAL SUPREMACY[1]
[1] _Remarks on the Royal Supremacy, as it is Defined by Reason,
History, and the Constitution_. A Letter to the Lord Bishop of London,
by the Right Hon. W.E. Gladstone, M.P. for the University of Oxford.
Guardian, 10th July 1850.
Mr. Gladstone has not disappointed the confidence of those who have
believed of him that when great occasions presented themselves, of
interest to the Church, he would not be found wanting. A statesman has
a right to reserve himself and bide his time, and in doubtful
circumstances may fairly ask us to trust his discretion as to when is his
time. But there are critical seasons about whose seriousness there can
be no doubt. One of these is now passing over the English Church. And
Mr. Gladstone has recognised it, and borne himself in it with a
manliness, earnestness, and temper which justify those who have never
despaired of his doing worthy service to the Church, with whose cause
he so early identified himself.
The pamphlet before us, to which he has put his name, is the most
important, perhaps, of all that have been elicited by the deep interest
felt in the matter on which it treats. Besides its importance as the
expression of the opinion, and, it must be added, the anxieties of a
leading statesman, it has two intrinsic advantages. It undertakes to deal
closely and strictly with those facts in the case mainly belonging to the
period of the Reformation, on which the great stress has been laid in the
arguments both against our liberty and our very being as a Church. And,
further, it gives us on these facts, and, in connection with them, on the
events of the crisis itself, the judgment and the anticipations of a mind
at once deeply imbued with religious philosophy, and also familiar with
the consideration of constitutional questions, and accustomed to view
them in their practical entanglements as well as in their abstract and
ideal forms. It is, indeed, thus only that the magnitude and the true
extent of the relations of the present contest can be appreciated. The
intrinsic greatness, indeed, of religious interests cannot receive addition
of dignity here. But the manner of treating them may. And Mr.
Gladstone has done what was both due to the question at issue, and in
the highest degree important for its serious consideration and full

elucidation, in raising it from a discussion of abstract principles to what
it is no less--a real problem of English constitutional law.
The following passage will show briefly the ground over which the
discussion travels:--
The questions, then, that I seek to examine will be as follow:--
1. Did the statutes of the Reformation involve the abandonment of the
duty of the Church to be the guardian of her faith?
2. Is the present composition of the appellate tribunal conformable
either to reason or to