Life and Habit | Page 2

or chicken doing the other." [This is
touched upon in the concluding chapter of "Luck or Cunning?" 1887].
The present edition of "Life and Habit" is practically a re-issue of that

of 1878. I find that about the year 1890, although the original edition
was far from being exhausted, Butler began to make corrections of the
text of "Life and Habit," presumably with the intention of publishing a
revised edition. The copy of the book so corrected is now in my
possession. In the first five chapters there are numerous emendations,
very few of which, however, affect the meaning to any appreciable
extent, being mainly concerned with the excision of redundancies and
the simplification of style. I imagine that by the time he had reached the
end of the fifth chapter Butler realised that the corrections he had made
were not of sufficient importance to warrant a new edition, and
determined to let the book stand as it was. I believe, therefore, that I am
carrying out his wishes in reprinting the present edition from the
original plates. I have found, however, among his papers three entirely
new passages, which he probably wrote during the period of correction
and no doubt intended to incorporate into the revised edition. Mr.
Henry Festing Jones has also given me a copy of a passage which
Butler wrote and gummed into Mr. Jones's copy of "Life and Habit."
These four passages I have printed as an appendix at the end of the
present volume.
One more point deserves notice. Butler often refers in "Life and Habit"
to Darwin's "Variations of Animals and Plants under Domestication."
When he does so it is always under the name "Plants and Animals."
More often still he refers to Darwin's "Origin of Species by means
Natural Selection," terming it at one time "Origin of Species" and at
another "Natural Selection," sometimes, as on p. 278, using both names
within a few lines of each other. Butler was as a rule scrupulously
careful about quotations, and I can offer no explanation of this curious
confusion of titles.
R. A. STREATFEILD. November, 1910.

AUTHOR'S PREFACE

The Italics in the passages quoted in this book are generally mine, but I
found it almost impossible to call the reader's attention to this upon
every occasion. I have done so once or twice, as thinking it necessary in
these cases that there should be no mistake; on the whole, however, I
thought it better to content myself with calling attention in a preface to

the fact that the author quoted is not, as a general rule, responsible for
the Italics.
S. BUTLER. November 13, 1877.



CHAPTER I
--ON CERTAIN ACQUIRED HABITS

It will be our business in the following chapters to consider whether the
unconsciousness, or quasi-unconsciousness, with which we perform
certain acquired actions, would seem to throw any light upon
Embryology and inherited instincts, and otherwise to follow the train of
thought which the class of actions above-mentioned would suggest;
more especially in so far as they appear to bear upon the origin of
species and the continuation of life by successive generations, whether
in the animal or vegetable kingdoms.
In the outset, however, I would wish most distinctly to disclaim for
these pages the smallest pretension to scientific value, originality, or
even to accuracy of more than a very rough and ready kind--for unless
a matter be true enough to stand a good deal of misrepresentation, its
truth is not of a very robust order, and the blame will rather lie with its
own delicacy if it be crushed, than with the carelessness of the crusher.
I have no wish to instruct, and not much to be instructed; my aim is
simply to entertain and interest the numerous class of people who, like
myself, know nothing of science, but who enjoy speculating and
reflecting (not too deeply) upon the phenomena around them. I have
therefore allowed myself a loose rein, to run on with whatever came
uppermost, without regard to whether it was new or old; feeling sure
that if true, it must be very old or it never could have occurred to one so
little versed in science as myself; and knowing that it is sometimes
pleasanter to meet the old under slightly changed conditions, than to go
through the formalities and uncertainties of making new acquaintance.
At the same time, I should say that whatever I have knowingly taken

from any one else, I have always acknowledged.
It is plain, therefore, that my book cannot be intended for the perusal of
scientific people; it is intended for the general public only, with whom I
believe myself to be in harmony, as knowing neither much more nor
much less than they do.
Taking then, the art of playing