The city, however, endeavors to collect on three
dogs--one license for each head. Two infernal coppers, sent to impound
Cerberus, fare not well, one of them being badly chewed up by
Cerberus, the other nabbed bodily and thrown into the Styx. In
consequence of this they obtain damages from the city. The city then
decides to bring suit against the state. The bench consists of Apollyon
himself and Judge Blackstone; Coke appears for the city, Catiline for
the state. The first dog-catcher, called to testify, and asked whether he
is familiar with dogs, replies in the affirmative, adding that he had
never got quite so intimate with one as he got with him.
"With whom?" asks Coke.
"Cerberus," replies the witness.
"Do you consider him to be one dog, two dogs, or three dogs?"
Catiline objects to this question as a leading one, but Coke manages to
get it in under another form: "How many dogs did you see when you
saw Cerberus?"
"Three, anyhow," replies the witness with feeling, "though afterwards I
thought there was a whole bench-show atop of me."
On cross-examination Catiline asks him blandly: "My poor friend, if
you considered Cerberus to be three dogs anyhow, why did you in your
examination a moment since refer to the avalanche of caninity, of
which you so affectingly speak, as him?"
"He is a him," sturdily says the witness. After this Coke, discomfited,
decides to call his second witness: "What is your business?" asks Coke,
after the usual preliminaries.
"I'm out of business. Livin' on my damages."
"What damages?"
"Them I got from the city for injuries did me by that there--I should say
them there--dorgs, Cerberus."
And so on. Catiline gains the day for the state by his superior logic; the
city of Cimmeria must content itself with taxes on a single dog. But the
logic of the facts, it will appear, are with the dog-catchers, Judge Coke,
and the city of Cimmeria as against the state of Hades: Cerberus is
more than one dog.
FUTURE LIFE IN THE VEDA.
India is the home of the Cerberus myth in its clearest and fullest
development. In order to appreciate its nature we must bear in mind
that the early Hindu conceptions of a future life are auspicious, and
quite the reverse of sombre. The statements in the Veda about life after
death exclude all notions of hell. The early visions are simple, poetic
and cheerful. The bodies of the dead are burned and their ashes are
consigned to earth. But this is viewed merely as a symbolic act of
preparation--cooking it is called forthright--for another life of joy. The
righteous forefathers of old who died before, they have found another
good place. Especially Yama, the first mortal, has gone to the great
rivers on high; he has searched out, like a pioneer, the way for all his
descendants: "He went before and found a dwelling which no power
can debar us from. Our fathers of old have traveled the path; it leads
every earth-born mortal thither. There in the midst of the highest
heaven beams unfading light and eternal waters flow; there every wish
is fulfilled on the rich meadows of Yama." Day by day Yama sends
forth two dogs, his messengers, to search out among men those who are
to join the fathers that are having an excellent time in Yama's company.
THE TWO DOGS OF YAMA.
The tenth book of the Rig-Veda contains in hymns 14-18 a collection of
funeral stanzas quite unrivaled for mythological and ethnological
interest in the literature of ancient peoples. In hymn 14 there are three
stanzas (10-12) that deal with the two dogs of Yama. This is the
classical passage, all depends upon its interpretation. They contain
detached statements which take up the idea from different points of
view, that are not easily harmonized as long as the dogs are merely
ordinary canines; they resolve themselves fitly and neatly into a pair of
natural objects, if we follow closely all the ideas which the Hindus
associated with them.
In the first place, it is clear that we are dealing with the conception of
Cerberus. In stanza 10 the two dogs are conceived as ill-disposed
creatures, standing guard to keep the departed souls out of bliss. The
soul on its way to heaven is addressed as follows:
"Run past straightway the two four-eyed dogs, the spotted and (the
dark), the brood of Saram[=a]; enter in among the propitious fathers
who hold high feast with Yama."
A somewhat later text, the book of house-rite of [=A]çval[=a]yana, has
the notion of the sop to Cerberus: "To the two dogs born in the house of
(Yama) Vivasvant's son, to the dark and the spotted, I have given a
cake; do ye guard me ever on my road!"
The
![](qr/23280/3.png)
Continue reading on your phone by scaning this QR Code
Tip: The current page has been bookmarked automatically. If you wish to continue reading later, just open the
Dertz Homepage, and click on the 'continue reading' link at the bottom of the page.