A Letter Addressed to the Abbe Raynal | Page 6

Thomas Paine
plundered multitude sat down and sorrowed. Few, very few of them are
accompanied with reformation, either in government or manners; many of them with the
most consummate profligacy.--Triumph on the one side, and misery on the other, were
the only events. Pains, punishments, torture, and death, were made the business of
mankind, until compassion, the fairest associate of the heart, was driven from its place;
and the eye, accustomed to continual cruelty, could behold it without offence.
But as the principles of the present resolution differed from those which preceded it, so
likewise has the conduct of America, both in government and war. Neither the foul finger
of disgrace, nor the bloody hand of vengeance has hitherto put a blot upon her fame. Her

victories have received lustre from a greatness of lenity; and her laws been permitted to
slumber, where they might justly have awakened to punish. War, so much the trade of the
world, has here been only the business of necessity; and when the necessity shall cease,
her very enemies must confess, that as she drew the sword in her just defence, she used it
without cruelty, and sheathed it without revenge.
As it is not my design to extend these remarks to a history, I shall now take my leave of
this passage of the Abbe, with an observation, which, until something unfolds itself to
convince me otherwise, I cannot avoid believing to be true;--which is, that it was the fixt
determination of the British Cabinet to quarrel with America at all events.
They (the members who compose the cabinet) had no doubt of success, if they could once
bring it to the issue of a battle; and they expected from a conquest, what they could
neither propose with decency, nor hope for by negociation. The charters and constitutions
of the colonies were become to them matters of offence, and their rapid progress in
property and population were disgustingly beheld as the growing and natural means of
independence. They saw no way to retain them long but by reducing them time. A
conquest would at once have made them both lords and landlords, and put them in the
possession both of the revenue and the rental. The whole trouble of government would
have ceased in a victory, and a final end put to remonstrance and debate. The experience
of the stamp act had taught them how to quarrel with the advantages of cover and
convenience, and they had nothing to do but to renew the scene, and put contention into
motion. They hoped for a rebellion, and they made one. They expected a declaration of
independence, and they were not disappointed. But after this, they looked for victory, and
obtained a defeat.
If this be taken as the generating cause of the contest, then is every part of the conduct of
the British ministry consistent, from the commencement of the dispute, until the signing
the treaty of Paris, after which, conquest becoming doubtful, they retreated to negociation,
and were again defeated.
Though the Abbe possesses and displays great powers of genius, and is a master of style
and language, he seems not to pay equal attention to the office of an historian. His facts
are coldly and carelessly stated. They neither inform the reader, nor interest him. Many of
them are erroneous, and most of them defective and obscure. It is undoubtedly both an
ornament, and a useful addition to history, to accompany it with maxims and reflections.
They afford likewise an agreeable change to the style, and a more diversified manner of
expression; but it is absolutely necessary that the root from whence they spring, or the
foundations on which they are raised, should be well attended to, which in this work they
are not. The Abbe hastens through his narrations, as if he was glad to get from them, that
he may enter the more copious field of eloquence and imagination.
The actions of Trenton and Princeton, in New Jersey, in December 1776, and January
following, on which the fate of America stood for a while trembling on the point of
suspence, and from which the most important consequences followed, are comprised
within a single paragraph, faintly conceived, and barren of character, circumstance and
description.

"On the 25th of December," says the Abbe, "they (the Americans) crossed the Delaware,
and fell accidentally upon Trenton, which was occupied by fifteen hundred of the twelve
thousand Hessians, sold in so base a manner by their avaricious master, to the King of
Great Britain. This corps was massacred, taken, or dispersed. Eight days after, three
English regiments were in like manner driven from Princeton; but after having better
supported their reputation than the foreign troops in their pay."
This is all the account which is given of these most
Continue reading on your phone by scaning this QR Code

 / 34
Tip: The current page has been bookmarked automatically. If you wish to continue reading later, just open the Dertz Homepage, and click on the 'continue reading' link at the bottom of the page.